Malaria remains a significant global health and economic burden, causing ~249 million cases and ~608,000 deaths in 2022 alone. Resistance has now developed to nearly all clinically available anti-malarials, highlighting the urgent need for new drugs with novel mechanisms of action (MoAs). Azithromycin is a safe and long-acting antibiotic that targets an essential parasite organelle of bacterial origin, the apicoplast, resulting in a delayed-death phenotype whereby parasite death is manifested only in the lifecycle after treatment initiation (~5 days). At higher treatment concentrations, azithromycin also has quick-killing activity independent of apicoplast targeting, leading to parasite death within the first replication cycle (~2 days). Chemical modification of azithromycin greatly enhances this quick-killing activity, however, the mechanism by which this occurs remains elusive. Here, we investigated the quick-killing mechanism of five azithromycin analogues, two of which contain chloroquinoline groups, structurally similar to chloroquine, an anti-malarial that targets the parasite’s digestion of haemoglobin. The non-chloroquinoline analogues demonstrated ~40-fold improvement in quick-killing across multidrug-sensitive and resistant lines, with chloroquinoline analogues being ~4-fold more potent. Experiments to test for evidence of chloroquine-like activity yielded conflicting results. Treating malaria parasites with the chloroquine resistance reversing agent, verapamil, and disrupting in vitro β-haematin formation linked chloroquinoline, but not non-chloroquinoline analogues to a chloroquine-like MoA. However, chloroquine-resistant parasites remained susceptible, and all analogues, not just the chloroquinoline ones, were antagonised when haemoglobin digestion was chemically inhibited. Furthermore, our most potent chloroquinoline analogue demonstrated activity against chloroquine-insensitive transmission stages of malaria parasites, the late-stage gametocytes. Application of thermal-shift proteomics to probe for alternative MoAs detected up to 291 impacted proteins, a remarkably high number with minimal overlap to chloroquine. These findings support that the bulk of the azithromycin-analogue quick-killing activity is likely driven by other non-chloroquine-like MoAs, broadly disrupting multiple cellular pathways in the parasite to rapidly induce death.